Hi Twodadspizza,
Here is what I suggest. Continue your research until you have identified 3-4 reputable companies that specialize in direct mail and pizza marketing. I suggest a company that also specializes in pizza marketing because they should have a deeper understanding of your design needs, should be able to help you with coupon suggestions, strategies (frequency & reach), etc. Make contact, give the company representative your current situation and let them propose multiple options.
Since every pizza shop owners needs are different in terms of budget, time, goals (long vs short term), etc., it’s important that you are aware of all of the options available not just what one company may have to offer, as there is no one size fits all with marketing and direct mail.
For example, a lot of pizza shop owners have success and like the EDDM option similar to Fat Boy & Bubba. However, for every one owner that we talk to and fulfill and EDDM job for, I can name 4 that don’t like the EDDM and choose other solutions.
Once you have all of the options and proposals, you will be able to make the best educated decision about which company is going to be the best partner and which product and strategy will yield you the best return.
PS: Please see the attached article about Reach Vs Frequency. I think you will find it informative and is crucial to understand when executing your marketing program.
Josh Davis
Mail Shark
Direct: 484-948-1611
http://www.themailshark.com