Piper, Check with your accountant about it. I am just repeating what ours has told me. Our restaurant is the third S-Corp business I have owned (in 19 years). We have had it now for going on 9 years. I have doen it this way with all three. I sold the first business to the employees in '94, the second is still running and third is the pizza biz.
At this point we take about 20K in W2 income (ALL of it goes into a SIMPLE plan so we pay no income tax on it) The rest of the income is in the form of dividends.
For the first 3-4 years we took no W2 income at all. We had a full time manager then as well. What my accountant told me was that for a couple of years you could post no W2 income and take the profit as loan repayments. He then advised us to start taking some income on the W2. We started the Simple plan at that point to put that income into retirement. (Setting up the Simple was pretty easy. We do our payroll with ADP and they have a pretty frictionless setup with Fidelity.)
According to what our guy has told us, if you already taking W2 wages, you can vary how much you pay yourself week to week or month to month. For example, you could take no pay at all for a while and pay yourself during the busy season. No need to increase your wage though. Just take the extra as dividends.
One good thing about W2 wages is that you can use them to completly avoid doing quarterly estimate payments. As long as the income tax is paid through withholding (W2) you can pay it in at any time of the year without penalty. This means that you could sit down and figure out your approximate tax liability in November, pay yourself that amount in one check and withhold 100% off it and be fine with the IRS. Of course, you have to pay SS on that money, so you don’t want to pay yourself more that way than you have to, but as long as you take W2 income, you might as well simlify the whole quarterly thing at the same time.
Again, I have been doing this close to 20 years, but am not an accountant. You should check with your accountant for sure as everyone’s situation can be different.