Vinny,
Help the board out and tell us what offers are getting tired so we don’t suggest the same thing.
For me it’s all about complete meal packages. Large pizza, breadsticks, salad, two liter for XX.XX. My demographics skew heavily toward families so they love those. We always build some sort of easy upsell into the offer. If you’re selling a package deal, always, always design it so there is an good upsell potential somewhere.
I’ve also had a lot of success in the past year with a free large cheese pizza with purchase of a large or extra large at menu price. They of course have the option of adding toppings for menu price. The cheese pizza costs about $1.20 all said and done, the customer sees a 12.99 value and I’m way better off than a $3.00 off coupon. More profit and more cash flow.