I have that same annoying delay. I answer “Thanks for calling Off Main Pizzeria” and they hear “…zeria”
You almost have to hit the button, make sure it turns solid (rather than flashing) and THEN wait 3 seconds to answer. To a certain degree… once you know the deal, not such a big deal but still a PITA.
When I was in Milford, NH (Domino’s) I would at least 10 orders/week for Milford CT, OH, MI and a few others.
Let me clarify that… people would come into the store after having placed their order (usually on-line but not always) and they CALLED or placed the order on-line CT, OH, MI, etc.
Oddly enough- I never got burned- meaning it was only that scenario, never that they would order in NH and walk into a store in CT, OH, MI, etc. Found that weird. I required pre-payment for OLO over $7 and we always answered the phone with the two towns we served “Thanks for calling Domino’s Pizza of Milford & Amherst” so maybe that helped but still odd.
People are stupid. Period.
More often than not, it was mom or dad who had their 9 year-old kid (not exaggerating) place the order either on-line (because what 9 year old doesn’t need a smart phone?) or call. For those that called I would always say “Well, the area code should have been a trigger” The reply I usually got was “Oh, I don’t know from area codes…
not even sure what this one is” Ummm… ok.
Re the GA or NY issue- only way to resolve that (on your end) would be a call catcher w/ a recording/greeting that
specifies NH. I had catchers in all my stores over the years.
As an aside… and then I’ll shut up… My home number in NH was one digit off from the Papa Johns store a few towns away. It was a new house I built, new number, etc. First few weeks… kept getting calls. “No, this isn’t PJ, they are XXX-XXXX” After a while, it got annoying but, because of my schedule (same as theirs, really!) it was never that big a deal.
I walk in w/ a friend one night after work and the phone rings. I go through my “No, this isn’t…” Guy starts to argue w/ me. Fine. “What can I get for you?” Take the entire order, upsell a 2L and then ask if he’d like a free order of Papa Stix (no such thing, as far as I knew). “Sure, thanks!”
“OK… be about 40 minutes… please turn your outside light on” I thought the “outside light” thing was a nice touch.