Good afternoon Daddio,
For pizzeria direct mail campaigns, an 11x17 menu is the ideal “standard” size/format (in my opinion).
Why Not 8.5x11?
When tri-folded, an 8.5x11 menu has a small 3.5" x 8.5" folded size …which is easy to miss. In most cases, households receive numerous letters, offers, and magazines on a daily basis that will dwarf the size of a folded 8.5x11 menu. This reduces your visibility, appeal, and ultimately, your conversion rates. While this is not the ideal-sized menu for direct mail, it still may generate a profitable ROI.
Why the 11x17 Works:
With an 11x17, the tri-folded size is at least 5" x 11" (for a tri-fold w/ coupon strip). This size is larger than a standard envelope, and basically “forces” the individual to handle your piece and decide “Do I want this or not?” The cover of your menu is critical here. Always include a benefit on the cover of your menu such as “Lower prices, Amazing Coupons - Look Inside!”
Even better, the new Every Door Direct Mail format requires an 11x17 menu to be a half-fold (flat) or half-fold with a coupon strip. This format increase the folded size to either 8.5x11 or 7.4x11, which is even more visible and more effective. The larger size also enables you to include beautiful food images, larger coupons, and easier-to-read font sizes. Your 11x17 menu will also stand out more when it is in the kitchen cabinet with a dozen other restaurant menus (for additional future sales).
With a turnkey design+print+mail program like the one we offer at Taradel, a few extra pennies per piece will enable you to use the 11x17 format over the 8.5x11 format, greatly enhancing your visibility, branding, and sales.
I’ve worked with hundreds of pizzerias and the average response rate (for a properly designed 11x17 menu) falls between 3% and 12.5% via direct mail. Your reputation, competition, food quality, service, offers, and even the weather can (and will) influence your ROI at the end of the day.
I hope this helps, thanks Daddio!