I use sugar in all of my doughs. Sugar feeds yeast - making it more active and quicker to develop. Some think adding sugar is unnecessary. Try both ways.
I use semolina in my Chicago style dough because it gives it that more coarse texture that I find desirable. I do not think it would be good in a New York style crust. Your “bite” in the crust should be inherent in the way you cook it. The best NY style crusts I have had have a slightly crispy and chewy outside with a thin soft bread like layer above that. I assume you are using a home oven. If so, put your stone all the way to the bottom. If you have a covered element, you don’t even need a rack. Set the oven (on bake NOT convection) as high as it will go (probably 500) and let it heat for at least an hour. Skip the screen that is recommended in your book for now. You want to wick as much moisture from the bottom of the crust as is possible. Sometimes I even open the oven door to fool the oven into cycling on.
Start out by trying the pizza on your home ovens highest setting. If that is too hot, turn it down a little for the next one.
Next, sauce is important. You will not find a good tomatoe in the grocery store. Escalon’s 6-n-1’s are available in small cans at specialty stores. Otherwise, find someone with a rest. depot membership and try out some of the escalon and stanislaus products to find one you like. I think a good start is mixing 6-n-1’s or full red with the stanislaus fully prepared. Spice it up a bit and see what you think. You will waste a lot of tomatoes by cooking at home. But that sauce recipe in the “Ultimate” book is garbage (ketchupy, yuck!).
I hope this helps. I’ve made lots of home pies (probably 500-700 in the past year). So I’ve made lots of mistakes and lots of terrible tasting pies. For whatever reason, I’ve found NY style to be the least forgiving even though it seems the simplest. Good luck.
I use semolina in my Chicago style dough because it gives it that more coarse texture that I find desirable. I do not think it would be good in a New York style crust. Your “bite” in the crust should be inherent in the way you cook it. The best NY style crusts I have had have a slightly crispy and chewy outside with a thin soft bread like layer above that. I assume you are using a home oven. If so, put your stone all the way to the bottom. If you have a covered element, you don’t even need a rack. Set the oven (on bake NOT convection) as high as it will go (probably 500) and let it heat for at least an hour. Skip the screen that is recommended in your book for now. You want to wick as much moisture from the bottom of the crust as is possible. Sometimes I even open the oven door to fool the oven into cycling on.
Start out by trying the pizza on your home ovens highest setting. If that is too hot, turn it down a little for the next one.
Next, sauce is important. You will not find a good tomatoe in the grocery store. Escalon’s 6-n-1’s are available in small cans at specialty stores. Otherwise, find someone with a rest. depot membership and try out some of the escalon and stanislaus products to find one you like. I think a good start is mixing 6-n-1’s or full red with the stanislaus fully prepared. Spice it up a bit and see what you think. You will waste a lot of tomatoes by cooking at home. But that sauce recipe in the “Ultimate” book is garbage (ketchupy, yuck!).
I hope this helps. I’ve made lots of home pies (probably 500-700 in the past year). So I’ve made lots of mistakes and lots of terrible tasting pies. For whatever reason, I’ve found NY style to be the least forgiving even though it seems the simplest. Good luck.
Last edited: